Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Welcome to Sportonomics, presented by Uncle Charlie. I'm Tyler Webb. And I'm Jake Krantz. 0:07 And today, Jake, in our last episode of twenty-twenty-three, we're going to be reviewing every single prediction we've made this year and rate their accuracy on a proprietary scale that I'll explain to you in a second. 0:18 And then we'll each give some sports business predictions for twenty-twenty-four. So hopefully- Great... this time next year, we can come back and review our predictions once again. 0:26 So Jake, a-after reviewing what you have said throughout twenty-twenty-three, how, how are you feeling about your predictions? Honestly, pretty good. [laughs] Pretty, pretty good. 0:36 I mean, you, you, you read, you read a lot of 'em. Maybe I wasn't, uh, wasn't playing enough hardball last year, but, um, I'm, I'm feeling pretty good about a lot of these predictions. 0:46 I, I had to intentionally pick one or two that were, were a miss, um, just in order to keep this interesting. Maybe, I might just be... I might, I might be a, uh, 0:58 I might be giving Punxsutawney Phil a run for his money on predictions. I think so. I, I did like a lot of your predictions, and we'll run through a lot of them here in a second. 1:07 Before we, uh, before that, we'll, we'll go over our scale. 1:10 I will say, I, I hope this year you, you brought some heat because as I was reading through some of your predictions from the beginning of this year, you, you had a few that seemed a little like, uh, softballs to me. 1:19 Like- Yeah. One... one that I-- o-one pointed out the companies with the most engaged audiences will outperform other companies. Like, you know, I, I, I kinda read then I said- Yeah... "Yeah, no duh." Fair. 1:29 Fair, fair, fair. But I will, I will also say that I think, uh, a part of what I was doing on that is, is just, like, saying the things that will never change. And- Sure... 1:40 uh, a-and, uh, we'll, we'll, we'll get to some of them. We'll get to some of them. But you are right. You are very right. So, so we're gonna, we're gonna bring the heat. 1:47 I, I brought the heat with some predictions at the end that are, I think, a little poignant, specific, I think could very well be proven right, could make me look really good. 1:55 It could also make me look like a total fool, so look forward to getting those. Before that, though, let's go over some that we did this year. 2:01 So we, we had an episode, it was episode five, sometime in July, that we both laid out some predictions for the remainder of the year. 2:06 And then at the beginning of this year, we, uh, called this out in an episode, a few episodes ago, uh, that you had written a nice LinkedIn post, "23 Predictions for 2023" in January of this year. 2:16 So we'll be kind of conglomerating, uh, a few of those different predictions, and we'll be rating them in a baseball-specific scale, so to go along with the sports theme. 2:25 If it's considered a strikeout, that means it was a total miss. You have a single, a double, a triple, all of which are different variations of correct. A home run, that's something that was exactly correct. 2:35 And then I wanted to throw a little something on top. 2:37 A grand slam is exactly correct, and then if there was a little detail in there that you specifically predicted, uh, you know, a specific element, I'll, I'll give you some bonus points, um, i-in the form of a grand slam. 2:49 So I pulled a few from yours and a few from mine. You pulled a few from yours, a few from mine. Let's just run through them in order. 2:56 I see that you have highlighted here first, Jake, that the average valuation for all major sports teams in the United States will increase by 10%. That was one of yours from the beginning of this year. 3:05 How do you feel about that one? I feel really good about it. Um- Yeah... I, I called it a triple, but now that I'm rereading what I wrote, I think that's a home run. I mean- All right... it k-kind of, uh, 3:15 it's kind of automatic actually. Um, the global average for the top 50 sports teams was an increase of 15%. Now, this was US specific. 3:24 Um, and every major US sports league had an average increase of more than 10%, so that's a dub. 3:31 Um, you look at the NFL, and the only team that appreciated by less than 10% was the Denver Broncos, but they've been an absolute dumpster fire, and their- Mm-hmm... their increase was 5%. 3:41 I think, I think the closest team to them was, like, a 15% increase. Yeah. The, the reason I listed this as a triple is because this is, I don't know, just, like, a technicality thing. It's... 3:55 There's, there's not really a, a proper way to actually value these teams. It's more so just a number on a whiteboard, and they say, "Hey, that's what we think this team is worth based off of whatever the factors are." 4:08 It's normally what was the most recent team sold for. It's normally- Mm-hmm... how big is the market, and then how, like, how is it doing, um, competitively on the field. 4:18 But we don't really have a look into inside of the financials of, of any of these organizations, um, nor will we probably ever. And, uh, so for that reason, I think I, I just place it as a triple because 4:31 it's not really a fair, fair... It's not a really fair, uh, fair scale to- Yeah... to, to rate teams on. You d- you know- Well-... you just never know. 4:39 I, I think you did a great job, and I, and I do think if, if I were to make a guess for this percentage increase in, in the coming year, I think given the rise of these MLS franchises, um- Yeah... 4:49 that have seen the, the Messi bump, y-you could probably safely predict a, a 20 to 25% increase, especially across the top teams in sports. 4:57 And I, I think that's an interesting trend that you're seeing where the top teams in each sports are the ones that are sort of making up, it seems, for a lot of the, you know, a lot of the, the big growth numbers. 5:08 And then you have a pretty high floor still where, like you said, there, there was no team in any league that really grew less than 10%, but, uh, you still have, it seems like a lot of the growth consolidated at the top. 5:19 Yeah. Um, it's hard to know too. 5:21 Like, it, it was interesting to see the, uh, the spread of it across the leagues 'cause on a percentage basis, the smaller teams theoretically have an easier pathway to more percentage growth- Right... 5:35 because the bigger team is already valued at a, a, such large number. Um, so that's, that's definitely a factor as well. 5:42 Um, I, I'd also say, like, I don't know if it's safe to predict that the average valuation will increase by 20% plus, but as more teams and leagues are allowing private equity to get involved, that takes the overall pie, uh, of people or, uh, dollars that can get invested into, um, into sports teams and leagues from, like-Maybe a few hundred people to thousands of different- Mm-hmm... 6:13 people or organizations that can invest in these things. So I, I think that only is beneficial for these companies. Which in turn drives up the, the total valuation because there's- Yeah, right... 6:25 more money- Just more money... chasing- Yeah... a set amount of goods. 6:28 Um, and I think this is going to be a trend going forward, and this isn't one of my official predictions, but, like, when you look at, uh, some of the, the, the oil, you know, sovereign wealth money that comes in from the Middle East, increasingly it seems like those types of groups, you know, whether, whether you consider it oil money or even domestic private equity money, are going to be the only groups that can afford the increasing prices of these teams. 6:50 It's just getting so ridiculous that you're pricing out more and more people. 6:54 Um, and it seems like the only way to acquire a, you know, a Denver Broncos, or most recently we saw the Washington Commanders get sold, is to put together some sort of a purchase ownership group that's- Yeah... 7:04 comprised of, you know, multiple different sources, minority stake investors, and not just the traditional, you know, one rich guy anymore. Well, no. Okay. Well- There's nothing- Interesting... rich guys. 7:16 [laughs] Not- There's a lot of rich guys. Yeah. Not enough rich guys to- Yeah. There's not, not enough people that are walking around with 10 billion they can drop on a team. Yeah. Okay, your next prediction. 7:26 TikTok will not get banned in the US, something that I'm glad didn't happen. It seemed like we sort of had a, a hype cycle at the beginning of this year where it seemed- Oh yeah... 7:34 I'm not gonna say inevitable, but I would've given it a 50/50 shot that it would or would not have. 7:38 Maybe as we get into the election here, it'll be, um, for 2024 here in the States, it'll be more of a, a, a pressing issue, but maybe you've done some research into this. 7:46 I'm not seeing a lot of movement or even excitement around this. Um, it doesn't seem like something that really moves voters or constituents. But, um, you know, I, I consider this correct. But what do you say? Uh, yeah. 7:58 It, it is, it is correct. I gave it a double or triple because I still do think that there is a looming risk of it getting banned in 2024. 8:06 Um, heck, could [laughs] should happen in 2023, but government doesn't work that fast, so probably 2024 at this point. 8:13 Um, behind the scenes, it has kind of been, I'll, I'll say shadow banned by the US government and, uh, a lot of the state governments too. 8:22 So Texas and then 33 other state governments have banned TikTok on, um, government-issued electronic devices, as has the federal government. 8:33 And so, um, for whatever that's worth, it is kind of banned, uh, for, for those devices and, and those individuals using those devices. That said, to the general public, still accessible. And so- Mm... 8:48 in that way, this is correct. 8:50 But if you look at the things that have been happening in the background, it's been getting banned by more and more states throughout the course of the year, which I think is, is very interesting. And, um, 9:01 it's, uh, probably a very, very much so a cause for concern for TikTok. Yeah, I think so. 9:08 I, I think at the same time, this Q4 push they're, they're clearly making to ingratiate TikTok into our, uh, purchase behavior, something that Jake, you, and I talked about, uh, privately the other week, how, how TikTok Shop just seems to be absolutely dominating people's for you pages, and, and talking to a lot of- Mm-hmm... 9:26 small businesses, they're making a ton of money. 9:28 And if I were to take this notion to its logical extreme, you know, I think a lot of these businesses are seeing TikTok as, as a boon for their bottom line, and I don't think it's in their incentive to have it banned. 9:40 I, I think if you ask most people, they don't wanna see it banned, and I, I just don't know where any momentum would be conjured from if not just from, you know, the government and their, uh, based on their own whims. 9:53 But it, it doesn't seem like publicly there's, there's any support or momentum for that. No. There, there is one group of people that want it banned. Who's that? Everybody at Meta. [laughs] Right. And, and, and Google. 10:05 Yeah. Fair. [laughs] Well, yeah. I, I mean, I think they would... They in the- They have anti-... have the preliminary discussions. Yeah. Totally. Well, I don't even think that's so much it. 10:16 They, this, this is probably the best use of their lobbying dollars is to ban another app, and I, I don't think... 10:23 It, it, I only say that because they're, they can hide under the guise of national security and, um- Yeah... you know, like this anti-China stuff. 10:30 And, of course, it does benefit them in, in a, uh, in a monopolistic, from a monopolistic standpoint, but they don't have to come out and say that outright. 10:37 Or at least they don't have to say that's what their intentions are. Yeah. Let's, let's come back to the national security thing when we get down to, down to FTX. Um- Okay... but the next, the next thing here is BeReal. 10:47 Mm. The prediction. This, this was, like, the most money prediction. [laughs] Um, and so BeReal, uh, BeReal flatlined, then began to lose users rapidly. Okay. Tyler sees a chart in front of him, um- Mm... 11:01 that shows that MAU, which is monthly active users, in millions over the course of the last, ooh, roughly three years. 11:08 So, uh, BeReal launched, I think it was in 2020, and then didn't really pick up any momentum until 2021. It was this kind of this, like, exclusive thing. 11:17 You could only get in by way of an invite, and you could, you could do it in that way. So they kind of rode the same hype cycle as a lot of the other social apps that, that are launching. 11:27 I forget, what was the name of the, uh... What was the, the name of the audio-only one club? Clubhouse? Yeah. Clubhouse. Clubhouse. Did the same exact thing. 11:34 Um, and so you saw that it, it picks up from 2021 to July of 2022 to 21.6 million monthly active users. 11:45 And in 2021, they maxed out at 900,000 monthly active users, which is a very significant jump over the course of just, like, six months. 11:54 And then in August of 2022, it was 73.5 million, um, and then you see it start to dip. 12:02 So there's not really a clear indicator of when it actually peaked, but my guess is it peaked at some point in the end of 2023, and over time it has, it, it flatlined, and now it's just starting toPlummet. 12:15 So, uh, February 2023, 47 million monthly active users. March of 2023, 33 monthly-- 33 million monthly active users. And then November of 2023, um, 12:30 roughly 25 monthly active users is what is, what is predicted for the app. So, um, essentially a third of what they had just over a year ago, uh, which is a very significant drop off. 12:44 So I'm calling that the first home run of the day because that was a very money call. I, I don't know why from like a business perspective, a lot of people thought this was work. 12:56 There's a- an app that actually Casey Neistat created, like- Mm-hmm... Beam 10 years ago, Beam, which was the exact same thing, and, uh, that didn't work. And- Mm... 13:08 uh, this, this was the same thing as Beam, had no business legs to stand on. Maybe it'll stick around a little bit longer, but as you'll see in my predictions for 2024, things aren't looking good for BeReal. Yeah. 13:22 I, I- Have you used BeReal recently? I, I, I use BeReal consistently still, and I, I think it's, it's one of my... It's definitely the social media app that I personally post on the most. 13:34 I would say it is the social media app I personally post on the most. Obviously, you know, I, I create content, uh, in, in more of a business context, but I'm not personally posting on Instagram or Facebook or Twitter. 13:44 I'm, I'm a consumer on all those platforms, but w- you know, posting about my personal life happens most consistently on BeReal. And, and I think there are a lot of... I think there are a lot of reasons for that. 13:54 Like, I, I love the exclusivity. 13:56 I love the fact that there's sort of a walled garden around the people that I, I wanna consume and engage with, um, and there's not like this algorithmic, algorithmic component that is being forced down my throat. 14:07 At the same time, I totally agree with what you're saying. I, I never understood how they would make any amount of money. 14:12 Um, [chuckles] there, there were very limited ways for them to, uh, like even evolve or iterate on, on the concept. 14:19 Like they, they did something recently where if you post your BeReal on time, you get two bonus BeReals throughout the day. Oh. So you could... A-and I'll be fair, was a bit of an incentive for me- [chuckles]... 14:28 'cause I, you know, I, I do like to be able to share with pe- you know, like other things I'm doing throughout the day, and BeReal kinda hamstrings you to the, the time and the place that you're currently at. 14:36 But, um, you know, at the same time, you're, you're totally right. 14:39 There, there was no way really that they could ever integrate advertising in a way that would feel meaningful or, you know, beneficial to, to their business case. 14:46 Um, and, and you also saw a million other apps, Instagram and TikTok included, just integrate BeReal as a feature into their- Within a week... existing apps. Within a week. 14:54 [chuckles] And TikTok eventually shut that down. Instagram eventually shut that down. Yeah. But it's just like one of those- Well, because people didn't use it, right? And like- Right... 15:03 I mean, it's just one of several other features that you can use within that app, but that's probably a, a pretty strong leading indicator for what is to come. Yeah. 15:11 Well, which app- You look at, you look at something like Stories on s- from Snapchat, and those stuck around on Instagram and Facebook. And so, I mean, Snapchat's still around. We'll talk about that in a little bit. 15:21 But what was your question? Which app do you think is gonna have a, a longer lasting impact? Because I think BeReal and Clubhouse both had, 15:28 at their, at their highest peaks, were like some of the most talked about social platforms- Mm-hmm... um, like to be launched. It's, it's very hard to launch social platforms in, in such a complicated space. 15:36 But they managed to cut through for some amount of time, and then had spectacular, you know, failings, where they went from the most talked about to the least talked about. 15:46 Which app do you think would ha- or is going to have the longest impact or, you know, space in our, in our memory? Do you think BeReal will have- Between those two? Yeah. Ooh, uh, probably BeReal. 15:56 I mean, there's this more- Oh, interesting... more like, more like general- Mm... population that uses BeReal as opposed to Clubhouse. I think Clubhouse was a lot of just like business people that were- Yeah... 16:07 looking for the next social app to, to- Yeah... um, take advantage of, and, um, but didn't really work out too well. But BeReal, like a lot of people used it, and still- Yeah... 16:17 like you, like a lot of people still do use it. I just don't think it, uh, has legs to stand on. Now, that said, like, I think, uh, if I'm them, 16:27 they're probably not thinking about how do we monetize this from an advertising perspective. They're trying to figure out how do we make this like a freemium model where people- Right... can pay for a subscription. 16:35 And one company I think it'd be really interesting to understand the financials behind is VSCO. Um- Mm. I, I, I haven't used the app in- Mm... 16:46 since high school, so probably my junior, senior year of high school, so it's been a while. Um, don't wanna age myself, but, um, pretty much every single girl that I know still has a VSCO link in their Instagram profile. 17:01 Um- Wow... and that's where a lot of people like document their, their lives. Um, it's... 17:07 A-and for whatever reason, instead of using just Instagram, like it's more, it's more private way of keeping track of things in a, in a curated way. 17:15 And so they have like a, a subscription-based model now where you're able to upgrade into certain features, and it would be kind of interesting to see what that business actually looks like, 'cause they don't do a ton of marketing. 17:28 Um, they have this really interesting viral loop of all females within our generation that basically have one in their Instagram profile. Right. Um, and so they, they're able to rely on that for the most part. 17:42 And so, I don't know, it'd be interesting to, to see that a little bit, 'cause they've never really had that same flywheel spinning that, like a BeReal or Clubhouse had. 17:54 Like, they're just never, they're never like a very popular thing in- Yeah... pop culture or business culture or anything. And I think they're owned and operated by somebody else right now, like somebody acquired them. 18:05 But probably an interesting little business that's, that's been around for a long time and just is, has been quietly operated and probably doing pretty well. Yeah. 18:14 I think another interesting company to dig into is Tumblr. Um- Interesting... I recently did an interview with their, well, now their parent company. Um, they're owned by WordPressUm, and they, 18:27 similarly, the, the CEO of WordPress is talking about how Tumblr just, like, exists in this very niche, like, purposely niche space, and maybe there isn't a mass appeal for what the app can be, but to the people who it matters to, there's a lot of, you know, like, user loyalty and engagement. 18:44 Uh, I also don't know why BeReal hasn't gone the direction, and maybe this is intentional, but, like, 18:49 why haven't they gone the direction of saying, "Hey, this famous person that you like to follow, um, you know, like, you can get a more intimate look into their life," and maybe based on some, you know, freemium model, or they could just leave it open and free and, and try to create a viral loop that way, where you can follow, you know, your most fame- your most favorite celebrities and get insight into what they're doing at specific times, and lean into- So, like, like, almost-... 19:13 that... almost like a, a PG-rated OnlyFans? Yeah, I mean, I, I don't think [laughs]... Yeah. In, OnlyFans in the sense that it's, like, a- getting access that you wouldn't otherwise get on other social media apps. Yeah. 19:26 Yeah. I- And you don't have, then you have to pay for the access. Yeah, something like that. So I- Yeah, cool... I, I don't know what, I don't know what BeReal ends up being. 19:33 I think these apps that just are easily folded into features. I mean, the reason I asked about, um, Clubhouse versus BeReal earlier is because I personally think Clubhouse is going to have a, a longer lasting effect. 19:42 Maybe we forget the name sooner, but I think, like, the notion of Twitter Spaces i- is still pretty popular in today's, um, lexicon, you know, public lexicon. Yeah. 19:51 So, and then that all originated because everybody was trying to copy Clubhouse after they had success with audio spaces, and, you know, you saw Meta, you saw Twitter obviously integrate those, that feature into their app instead of just having it be a standalone app. 20:06 And, you know, I think Twitter Spaces are still pretty popular, and, and maybe not the most successful feature on the app, but, um, something that still exists and something we still talk about. 20:15 So, I think it's interesting, but if you're gonna start a social media app, maybe don't have it be something that can be replicated within a week. Yeah. Well, this is... I'm, I'm, I'm just digging into VSCO right now. 20:23 It's crazy. So they've, they haven't raised money since 2014 or 2015. So I think 2015's- Yeah... the last time. They, they raised a series A and a series B. And, uh, 20:33 in 2018, they got to 30 million users, and I'd assume it's probably still pretty similar if not, if not much more than that now- Yeah... at this point. So they're probably a sneaky big company. Maybe. 20:46 A- another, another way BeReal can go, I... We don't have to keep hammering on BeReal, but there was an app, it was just this, a concept that was popular in maybe about five years ago. 20:54 An app that helped you facilitate this concept. 20:56 It was called One Second Every Day, and you would take a one-second video, and you got to choose when that video was, but you took a one-second video and you did that 365 times throughout the year, and at the end of the year, it put it together in this cool compilation where- Three minutes... 21:09 you got to see your year play out over a second. And so maybe they're, you know... 21:13 A- and I mention that in the context of VSCO because they seem to lean more into the functionality of, like, you can pay for, you know, photo filters and- Sure... different effects that you can add. 21:23 And so they're, they're clearly trying to appeal to people as, you know, like, as a, as a photo editor, and then the distribution is sort of secondary. 21:31 And maybe BeReal leans into a different, a different, like, effect than trying to be a social platform. So maybe it's saying like, "Hey, you are already doing this thing. 21:40 You can pay to, you know, receive, like, a really cool memento from your year," and then dist- the distribution is sort of a, a secondary effect of that. I don't, I don't know. It... 21:49 BeReal, you're getting free advice from, from Jake and I, and at the end of the day, none of it will probably really matter. Yeah, you can't cash that advice at the bank, so I, I would just throw it away at this point. 21:59 Okay, speaking of a social platform that does matter a little bit more. 22:02 Uh, Jake, you predicted that Snapchat will grow in terms of total users, but the frequency of use will fall, and their ad revenue will slip because of it. So, I'm rating this as a double, uh, for a, a few reasons. 22:14 So you, you were correct in the sense that it will grow in terms of total users. So it's actually grown its user base by more than 10% year over year for the past 16 quarters consecutively. 22:24 So they've had sustained growth for the past couple of years now at this point. Yep. Um, most of that growth has actually happened in India, ironically, maybe not so ironically, but interestingly. 22:34 Um, part of my prescription of that is because TikTok is banned in India. Snapchat has obviously been one of these apps that has tried to create a TikTok competitor. 22:42 I actually think in the context of, you know, you hear a lot of talk these days in America about a super app. I think Snapchat is probably closer than Twitter- Twitter... in a lot of places- Yeah... 22:51 as being a super app because they have great content distribution, whether it be on, like, their Spotlight product where you can scroll. 22:57 Um, they have their Stories where you can, again, like, take in content from your friends or discover new content. 23:02 And then they're a really powerful messaging app, and that's what, probably what a lot of people use it for. So in the context of having, like, a multi-use media app, I, I think Snapchat- Hmm... 23:10 is actually doing a really good job. It's gonna be Wa- it's gonna be WhatsApp, but yeah, I agree. Yeah. Fair enough. [laughs] So [laughs] 23:16 to, to kind of, like, counter your, your prediction here, um, the app is losing money. Um, so it, it has not turned a profit still. 23:23 Lost $1.4 billion last year, which is actually more money than it's ever lost, and the valuation in turn slipped, uh, from a high of $90 billion in 2021 to last year having a valuation of just $38 billion. 23:36 So it was cut in about a third. It still lags behind apps like Pinterest, Reddit, and even LinkedIn in terms of its daily active users. 23:44 Um, a point about usage, you mentioned that the frequency of use will fall, and that will in turn cause ad revenue to slip. So usage is actually up. So in 2020, uh, users opened the app 20 times per day. 23:56 In 2023, that is up to 30 times per day. So people are interacting with the app more frequently. I think a large part of that, again, is because they're diversifying the type of media that you can consume. 24:06 Not only is it a messaging app, you can go on there for, you know, scrollable content. You can go on there for stories, discover different shows, and stuff like that. 24:13 Um, but revenue is down, um, not necessarily because ad revenue is down because of decreased usage, but because they're paying creators a boatload of money right now. 24:22 Uh, but I, I'm assuming their advertising revenue is up because their advertisable space has increased. Now you, now you can advertise a bunch ofAcross a bunch of different, you know, content verticals. 24:31 So I'm giving you a double on this. You, you, you did correctly predict it will increase in terms of total users, but the frequency is up, and, and I assume the average- No, I'm giving double... is probably also up. 24:41 No, I'm giving- Okay. No, I'm giving double. Yeah. Maybe a single. Yeah, maybe a, maybe a single. I think the sentiment here was, like, that Snapchat is moving up in the, the age vertical, so more- Mm-hmm... 24:52 more older people are starting to use the app. 24:53 And I think my thought process was, okay, if more people are starting- gonna start to use the app, the power users will start to go away at, at the, at the, in the younger age groups, and so people will just start to use it less frequently. 25:08 Um, and because of that, the ad revenue will slip. So I thought it was super interesting to see that their usage is actually up year over year. 25:16 I wonder what, like, the overall time spent within the app was in 2022 compared to 2023. Um, that would be kind of an interesting thing to, to understand as well. 25:29 I would, I would assume that it'd probably be similar or a similar trend- Yeah... or close to what you saw in, in, in terms of, like, the app openings. But you never know. 25:38 Maybe they're just really good at sending push notifications now [chuckles]. Yeah, it's possible. I... So I, I did see in my research that their usage time is about on par with, like, an Instagram. Um, so they're- Oh... 25:48 they all kind of l- they all still lag behind TikTok. Um, TikTok's by far the most used app in terms of time used. Mm. But- Uh-huh... 25:55 um, you know, they're shorter sessions, but they all kind of equal up to about an Instagram or a YouTube level of usage. I don't have the percent change for you. 26:04 If I had to guess, it would probably be more than it was in 2020, just again, simply- Right... because the content on the app is much more built out. You can go on there, and you can do more than just message somebody. 26:14 Uh, I, I think the story of Snapchat in the last year has been they're clearly leaning into a content distribution model, and it's nice that they have the, the messaging component, and that part will likely never change. 26:25 But they wanna keep you on the app longer. My guess is they saw people opening the app 20 times per day, which is probably more than most apps. 26:32 But they saw their session time was pretty low because you, you open it, you send a message, you leave. 26:36 And they wanted to say, "Hey, if we could, you know, likely, if we could increase your session time by 20%- Oh, cool. [chuckles]... could we... Yeah, c- could we also consequently increase revenue by 5% to 20%?" 26:47 Um- Yeah... and they're doing a, a really aggressive job at trying to get people to come over- [chuckles] Yeah... and create content for them. And I, I, I think my, 26:56 my point of curiosity with Snapchat is, is how much longer is that going to keep up? 26:59 You, you hear about these creators making literally millions of dollars a week, you know, hundreds of thousands of dollars a day on Snapchat because of these, like, ridiculous $10, $20 CPMs, and their stories are getting pushed to, um, new and, and [chuckles] new audiences that don't already follow them. 27:15 And, uh, if you can get people to click on your stories and click through a few, you're, you're racking in 10 to 20 bucks every time somebody sw- swipes through a couple story slides, which again can take people seconds to, to tap through. 27:26 So it's interesting, man, and, and I don't know if, uh, if that's a sustainable model. They lost $1.4 billion last year. Mm. 27:32 But I, I think they're probably seeing it as an upfront investment to get creators and then get the, you know, content consumption habit over to their app. 27:39 And maybe at some point, they try to flip on the profitability button. Yeah. Uh, it's, uh... It is an interesting model that they've, they've wandered their, their selves into. 27:48 Like, I think they probably saw, hey, people are just using our app for, for messaging, and then they switch over to, like, uh, Instagram or TikTok in order to consume content. 27:57 And then if they some- somebody sends them a snap back, then they go back over to Snapchat, and then they go back over to TikTok once they respond to that person. So yeah. I, I think you're right, though. 28:06 I mean, it could be interesting to see them become the first true super app inside of America. Yeah. I, uh, [chuckles] it's... I just struggle. 28:14 Th- Snapchat has always been my favorite example of, like, the, the, the startup from the mid-2010s that has been so focused on user growth and has pushed profitability down the road. 28:24 You know, they're, like, so focused on user acquisition- Mm... that they can keep telling their investors, like, "We'll just be able to turn this switch on once, you know, once we get a, a certain amount of users." 28:32 And they clearly haven't done that yet, and they've actually gone the opposite direction, where they've [chuckles] actively lost more money to get- Yeah... more users and acu- profitability further down the road. 28:42 And I just wonder how much longer they can go to their investors and say, "Hey, this is a, a sustainable model." 28:48 It, it seems like they're sort of the last true holdout to not have to flip that profitability button on, and I just wonder how much longer that can last. Yeah, I don't know. I don't know. 28:57 I mean, as long as you're telling a compelling story to investors, I suppose it doesn't matter. And their story has been sustained growth, especially internationally, and now they have this content distribution thing. 29:06 So maybe they bought themselves a couple years. But in any case, next prediction, Jake. The legalization of sports betting will be the main driver behind live sports viewership. So this one was interesting to dig into. 29:17 A bit subjective on the rating, but to give you some hard numbers, the NFL viewership- Yeah... has increased every year since sports betting was legalized in 2017. 29:25 So between then and 2022, there's been a 20% increase in viewership, which is kind of crazy because when you consider how much viewership the NFL gets, by far the most out of any league, the fact that they could eke out 20% more- Mm. 29:35 Mm-hmm... it's hard not to contribute that to sports betting. Mm. Uh, similarly, the MLB attributes, uh, sports betting, uh, to a huge uptick in fan engagement. 29:44 As compared to an average fan, somebody who's a sports bettor is 40% more likely to stream a game, 36% more likely to buy a ticket, and 30% more likely to read an article on MLB.com. Mm. 29:53 Uh, I think just this general idea of adding sports betting to sports, especially like MLB and the NBA, where you can add stakes and urgency to regular season games that don't have a lot of stakes and urgency built in is probably being... 30:05 is probably really helpful to these leagues. Um, and with all that considered, I, I'm gonna give this a triple. I don't think it's a home run because I, I think it's hard to 30:14 associate the increase in, in viewership across all these sports specifically to sports betting. I, I think it's probably a top three reason. 30:20 I would make the argument, and I'm curious to hear your thoughts, that things like new rules, um, just the, uh, better execution of, of media and expanded media rights probably has more to do with the increase in viewership than sports betting. 30:32 You're making a face like you disagree.No, I would not disagree with you at all. Okay. I think those are all certainly factors. I just kind of had that face on me today. I'll, I'll take it off. Um, 30:43 the NFL one's super interesting. There are no real changes there. [laughs] Right. And so somehow [laughs] I took that- Somehow, some way. Um, now, it, it is over a five-year span, so I guess that would be, what? 30:55 Four percent a year. So it's not- Yeah... 30:57 it's not super ridiculous, but this, this is also happening as this really weird transition happens between, um, linear television and, and streaming, uh, which is probably very confusing and makes, uh, viewership tracking a little bit, little bit more difficult. 31:13 Um, and the viewing experience, in some cases, a little bit more difficult for, for fans, especially for the NFL. 31:19 Like, they, like, with, with Thursday Night Football as an example, that completely took that off of the, the- They, they pay wall the product... platforms. Yeah, essentially. And, uh, viewership's up there, too, so 31:31 pretty interesting to see all of that. Um, it is impossible to pinpoint it to just that as a single factor, so, um, hey, Jake, maybe make a more well-thought-out- [laughs]... 31:42 action next year so it can actually be tracked. Uh, but I will... I, I don't think there's any doubt that it is definitely a contributing factor, and it's, I mean, it's, it's great for sports business. 31:52 It's great for the business of sport. Probably pretty bad for all the individuals that are, um, sports betting because their, their wallets are becoming a little bit thinner. 32:02 But yeah, they're watching it, and they're going to more games, and they're buying more things, and they're betting on the teams. It's good for sports business. 32:10 Yeah, this is a part of my prediction, um, later on for next year. I, I will be curious to see what the effect of something like an ESPN bet entering the, uh, the, the environment will do for, for sports viewership. 32:22 I mean, when, when you look at, and, and again, we'll talk about this more in my prediction later on, when you look at the, [sighs] the desire by a lot of sports betting companies, sports books, DraftKings, FanDuel, to reverse integrate back into media- Mm-hmm... 32:35 and you see really, like, their lack of effectiveness, like, nobody's really talking about a DraftKings or a FanDuel media property, you know, it, on a, on a daily basis. 32:44 Like, those only serve to act as promotions for their, their sports books, but they're not, like, standalone, really compelling products. 32:51 ESPN, on the other hand, has obviously a really compelling standalone sports media product being their- Yeah... their, their flagship networks and all their, you know, really popular personalities that, um, that exist. 33:00 And so I wonder, like, that seems to me like the first true marriage of, like, mainstream sports with sports betting. 33:06 It still seems like even though it's legal, sports betting has existed on the fringes of our, our media and public discussion, but now for the first time it seems like they are, uh, they're pretty squarely merging, and I wonder if that's gonna have a, a bigger effect. 33:18 And I, I think another thing with that is n- not just the, the distribution opportunity through ES- ESPN, but the credibility and trust that are built into that brand and, and that community of users, um, i- is unmatched. 33:35 And, and so I think that with, like, um, DraftKings, FanDuel, um, BetMGM, all these other sports books, they were kind of... 33:48 As you mentioned, they're on the outskirts, and they're, they're kind of, like, the, the, the cowboys in this situation. 33:54 Whereas, like, ESPN is just the trusted authority in the space, and if they say something, then that's just kind of reality. That's, like, that's, that's what is... That, that is what, what the, uh, 34:07 culture is saying can, can be done and should be done. 34:10 So if, if, uh, ESPN puts their stamp of approval on it, then I just think that opens the door for a lot more people to justify sports betting in their head as opposed to them going out and doing something that they feel is maybe not good for them, um- Yeah... 34:25 or, or, or good in general. So that might be another factor, too. A bit, uh, I mean, a bit scary, like, the implications that you kind of lay out- Yeah... 34:32 where, like, [laughs] especially when you talk about the, the incentives of the network. 34:37 Like, I, I know ESPN mentioned that guys like Woje and Adam Schefter aren't allowed to gamble, but when you look at the, the company- They don't get paid money either... yeah, right. But, like, what's... 34:48 You have to start questioning now, what, what, what is ESPN's incentive to get you to do? Is it to- Watch more of their content... get you to... 34:55 Is it to watch more of their content, or is it to put out content that would incentivize you to bet? That is very interesting. 'Cause the margins are higher on that. And so- Yeah... 35:04 I know they're not going to do that, and if they did that too consistently, they would probably just lose our trust and then, you know, like, f- s- fall in, in the stan- [laughs] in the public eye. 35:14 But I, I think it does call into question some interesting incentives that networks have. 35:18 Is, is it to get you to consume content which isn't a directly, as directly monetizable as you putting down 10 bucks and then possibly losing it because Adam Schefter tweeted a, a news report that could lead you to believe something? 35:30 Mm-hmm. No, that's, that's a great thought. I, I think there's some validity there, too. Yeah. And they have to tread very carefully. I think so. 35:38 Okay, uh, one, one, another one for me here before we hop over to a few more of yours. Creator-driven, uh, engaging content will perform better across digital channels as opposed to, quote-unquote, traditional ads. 35:49 I'm gonna put this one in the category of a little vague, Jake, um, but I wanted to, I wanted to mention it because I think- Pretty much makes up all of the predictions so far. Yeah. But yes. 35:59 I, I think, I think it is true, and I, I think we j- uh, the reason I highlighted it is 'cause we have some, some personal experience here. 36:04 I mean, like, on the agency side, um, all the, the clients that we're working with that are running paid advertising, um, have seen these creator-driven pieces of content outperform, um, you know, outperform any, quote-unquote, traditional ad. 36:17 You talk about, like, a graphic or just some generally promotional video by, you know, I, I would say cutting costs on a conversion by 40 to 50%. 36:25 I mean, I, I'm not wrong in saying that it has been that drastic in a, in a shift where- In some cases, for sure... yeah, in, in, in some cases. 36:32 And even speaking from my own experience as a creator, like, when I haveBrands reach out. They, you know, they, they like the organic content. You know, that's good. 36:40 It's hard to tie a lot of conversion events to a specific piece of organic content. However, they love to, to use it for, for promotional, uh, for promotional purposes as well. 36:51 And a lot of, a lot of these deals now include thirty, sixty-day usage rights for them to be able to promote it, um, you know, on, on paid, uh, TikTok paid ads or, or Facebook paid ads. 37:01 And so it seems like we're gonna continue to move in that direction. I'll also add a caveat in there where that seems to work really well for top-of-funnel content. 37:10 You know, when somebody-- you wanna introduce somebody to your brand, you wanna do it in a way that, um, speaks to them in a way that they're used to being spoken to. 37:17 But I still do think that when you're trying to get somebody over the edge, um, in a conversion event, when they've already seen your, your, your brand, and they're already familiar with what you do, I think being as short and direct as possible is probably the best way to go about doing it, because if you try to string them along for too long in some sort of, like, organic style video, I think you increase your chance of losing them. 37:37 Whereas if you're trying to get a point across with a, a discount or a specific feature or a specific benefit, just making that known to them up front, um, when they're already familiar with you is probably still the best way to go. 37:46 But worth mentioning there, I think it's a home run, um, and I think for-- from a creator perspective, that will probably continue to be the case. Mm-hmm. 37:54 And it might change what it l- like, what it looks like might change over time, but- Mm-hmm... ultimately the principle is still there. I think so. Um, all right, next thing. 38:03 Most c- more companies will be started within the US than have ever been started. There's a three to f- three to five percent reduction from the peak in twenty-twenty immediately following the, uh- Hmm... 38:13 the shutdown due to COVID. So I'm gonna call that a strikeout. Um, I will say this is the second highest year of all time. So [laughs] it's- Okay. Not too far off... that's, so that's something. 38:22 But it, it was actually super interesting to see the peak in the chart, um, in twenty-twenty between, like, April and August or September of that year. 38:32 There were th- like, it, it was, like, a dumb number of companies- Yeah. One of those pandemic-... that got started... bubbles Like, like, like a one hundred or two hundred percent increase, like, just- Right... 38:42 ridiculous number of companies that were started. And it was just people had a little bit of extra money. They're like, "Hey, like, we should start a company." And, uh, and so that was that. 38:50 It was, uh, yeah, pretty interesting to see, interesting to see that data. 38:54 Um, the next t-thing here is FTX will ultimately fold, but cryptocurrencies will become a more generally accepted form of payment, especially in smaller markets with struggling physical currencies like Argentina. 39:07 So FTX is still winding down technically. Um, its, its business is within, uh, still in-inside of the bankruptcy process, and their bankruptcy firm is, is taking care of all that stuff. 39:20 SBF, Sam Bankman-Fried, the, the figurehead of FTX, um, was just sentenced, and it's not looking good for him. 39:28 I watched the whole thing live, and, uh, things are, are [chuckles] uh, not looking great for, uh, his, his time- Yeah... remaining outside of, um, outside of bars. So there is that. 39:39 Um, interestingly, most people that had money inside of FTX are actually gonna come out at least even on this just because of how well these cryptocurrencies have been performing in the last year. 39:51 Like Bitcoin alone- Yeah... is up like a hundred plus, hundred fifty plus percent in, in the last fifty-two weeks. 39:59 Um, and so despite them, like, losing a lot of money in theory, they actually [chuckles] aren't really going to. 40:08 And so the, the fact that this happened is just, uh, it's a little bit ironic because if, if there wasn't, like, a, a huge dip that happened, 40:17 Sam Bankman-Fried would probably still be a free man, and, uh, there wouldn't be any consternation around him, him going anywhere because everybody would still have a bunch of money. 40:26 Um, and in reality, they [chuckles] they still do. He did a lot of things that were wrong and a lot of things that were illegal. But at the end of the day, it kinda netted out where everybody's still doing all right. 40:36 Um- Yeah. It, it- Yeah... is one of those things where it sucks that peop- some people did lose money. Um- For sure... it, it also, 40:44 like anecdotally at least, some of the most annoying people online were, like, these crypto people that were telling you how much money they were making. And so they were the ones that really got the worst of it. 40:52 Like, I don't, you know- They probably- The others- So they probably weren't. You're right. Y-y-you say that they're maybe the savviest of people. So okay, maybe you're right. Yeah. 41:00 The, I mean, a lot of those people had, uh, they, they had a lot of their assets in, in cold storage. Um, another thing that just popped up today, so the Binance CEO just pled guilty to federal charges. 41:13 I don't know what that's going to look like. I have no idea what the charges are. But that's probably not a really great thing for the crypto industry as a whole. 41:20 Despite all of these bad things that are happening, um, there are more people than ever that are, that are using this type of payment, um, or utilizing these assets as, uh, as like a value storage, um, container or just as an asset class. 41:38 And so I think that's, that's really, really interesting to see all that happen, um, in spite of all of the negative things that are happening within the industry. 41:49 And, uh, I, I, I mentioned we should bring this up at the, when we got to this section, but I think similar to ESPN and betting, um, I forget what we were talking about what that made me think we needed to bring this up. 42:01 But I, I think that the crypto indust-industry, at least inside of the United States, needs like a very trustworthy figure, brand, or organization to lead the charge in terms of security, um, stability, and trust. 42:20 Because I don't think that people really had that with these two platforms, um, Binance and FTX. 42:25 And I think they maybe see it in Coinbase a little bit, but I, I, I'm talking more so, like, maybe it's Bank of America or US Bank or like aWells Fargo type or like an Apple that gets into it and says, "Hey, like we're going to, we're gonna be the primary exchange for all of this. 42:47 We're gonna be the place where you can store all this stuff, um, and we'll make sure that it's extremely safe. It is not our core business. 42:55 Because of that, we can focus all of our time on security and privacy, and we don't have to focus on making extra money for ourselves." 43:04 Um, and, and by way of them doing that, I think they create like a really interesting business inside of their business that's just based off of trust and, and transparency. 43:13 I think that, that the crypto market really needs that. Yeah. And I think because of FTX, they'll have quite a large hill to climb, and will rightfully be under much more scrutiny, which I think the outcome... 43:24 If that's the outcome of all this is, is probably for the best. Yeah. Uh, you, you gotta watch this. There's a, um, I think Business Insider or o-one of the bigger companies. 43:34 They, they did like a full hour and a half long, um, I'll call it a documentary, but it was a short film on, uh, FTX and Sam Bankman-Fried. And it is very interesting to just watch and understand how it all came to be. 43:50 I think they released it a couple of months ago, so before the sentencing hap- actually took place, but after the, uh, initial allegations came out. 43:59 Um, so really, really interesting video, and it's on YouTube, so totally free on YouTube, and it's like an hour and 15 minutes maybe. So definitely worth the watch. 44:08 Um, lighter note, kind of a maybe a little bit more depressing note. The next prediction was Minnesota will win the Stanley Cup. Strikeout. We can go on to the next. Wah, wah. Yep. 44:17 [laughs] Uh, the virtual reality sector will be, uh, created with a clear path to profitability. Meta will benefit the most with the new hardware and software available in this space. 44:27 Jake, I gave this one a strikeout, uh, basically [laughs], basically on every level. All right. 44:32 Um, so, uh, path to profitability, Meta actually lost $3.7 billion just last quarter on their Reality Labs, and they've lost something to the tune of like $31 billion since the beginning of last year on, on Reality Labs. 44:45 So Oculus does make money, uh, but the broader like metaverse idea that exists within, uh, Meta, uh, Facebook is, seems to still be failing. 44:56 And I also think that the biggest winner this last year in like wearable VR/AR technology is actually Apple. I think whenever Apple jumps into a space, that's sort of the sign that it's, one, cool, and it's, two, 45:11 you know, a, a space that's now, that, that's now maybe a bit more acceptable than it was before. 45:17 And I think you see this with something like wireless headphones, like AirPods are in and of themselves like a, a Fortune 500 company, and before you kinda had these clunky versions of like wireless earbuds. 45:28 Apple Watches, like smart wearable devices always seem to benefit Apple and not benefit the first company that does them. I think it's just Apple. You know, Apple takes an extra beat to do that. 45:38 And I just think they've mastered the, you know, the sex appeal of a lot of these things which have traditionally not been seen as very sexy. 45:44 And the last thing I'll say is that it seems like, in all the marketing I've seen from Apple or from Meta, is that augmented reality, AR seems to be leading their efforts in, in development and even just their like forward-looking advertising more so than, than virtual reality. 45:59 I think there's still some stigma around people getting, I don't know what it is, motion sick. Maybe people just think they won't understand or won't appreciate what a V- a full VR experience is like. 46:08 And it seems like these companies are trying to lead us into full VR with augmented reality components, whether it be screens that are popping up on the, you know, on, on the Apple, uh, Vision Pro, but you can still interact with the space around you. 46:21 Or I saw that Oculus has a bunch of games where you're, you're, you're still standing in your bedroom or in your living room, and then there's just elements that are interlaced on top of your existing physical space. 46:33 And so I think that AR is probably going to, uh... AR is probably the biggest winner of this year, and not necessarily virtual reality quite yet. Yep. Strikeout. Okay. All right. Strikeout. From strikeout to grand slam. 46:46 As always, it will pay to be an optimist. That's the prediction. Mm. Still checks out. Still checks out. Still checks out. 46:53 Jake, you, you also had a prediction that said the tenure of a college athlete, and, and these are from June, so these are later on, uh- Yeah... will increase by at least one year. 47:00 You mentioned that there's not enough data, but I, I do think we're trending in the right direction here. I do, I do too. 47:04 Like, uh, subjectively, uh, the reason I said there's not enough data is 'cause there hasn't really been kept track of. Um, and I'm sure somebody will begin to keep track of it. 47:12 I'm not gonna go manually count it all, that's for sure. Um- [laughs]... but I think subjectively, I've been hearing a lot about fifth, sixth, seventh year guys and gals that are- Yeah... that are playing. 47:24 Now, you need to remove COVID from the equation, which complicates it a little bit because everybody got an extra year. So you gotta factor that into what is happening. 47:34 But if we get five, 10, 15 years down the road and we compare that to the 15 years prior to 2018 or 2019, um, I think that we see 47:48 a trend which does show that people are staying in college longer. Um, at least the athletes. Uh, hopefully not the individuals that are going to school there just to go to school there. 47:58 But the athletes, just because they're able to make more money as a college athlete than they might be able to at the professional level. I think the, uh, the canary in the coal mine here will be college basketball. 48:10 I, I think there's a lot of competing efforts for what has been the traditional one-and-done college basketball model. Yeah. I think a lot of people recognize that that doesn't work. 48:18 And so if somehow, still in a broken system, uh, a university is able to keep what would traditionally have been a one-and-done guy for an extra year because of those reasons that you just explained, they could make more money at college or make just as much money at college, I think that'll be a really good indicator for that prediction. 48:33 So I, I think we're trending in the right direction. Yeah. Maybe, maybe I should rephrase my prediction for, for future years. Maybe I should say like the, the age, like the o- like the average age of a... 48:44 college athlete will be at least a year or two higher than it, than it has been in the past. Correct. 48:49 Like, you look, like, on the hockey side of things with junior hockey, um, there are a lot older players that are playing at the college level- Yeah... just because they play a couple years of juniors. 48:59 And some of the best teams in the country are made up of, like, 26, 27-year-old [laughs]... guys that are freshmen. Yeah. 49:05 It's, like, crazy, but, um, uh, you're able to have somebody that has, like, an additional six years of development on a kid that's 18 years old and playing- Right... college hockey, so. 49:14 Well, I think it'll be helped by the transfer portal too, because now players can stay around in college more and not be penalized for moving schools. Yeah. 49:21 And if you can, without penalty, go to a different school for one more year and play one more year of college athletics even though you have no professional prospects but you just wanna do it because it's your, you know, it's your time to do it, I, I, I think we're already seeing that. 49:33 People are apt to, you know, go from a, let's say they were a, a D- you know, a, a, a three-star recruit to Georgia, and they're like, "You know what? 49:40 I just wanna play, and I just wanna get the college football experience," and the, so they transfer to Rice, and they do that at the age of 25 instead of just go- [laughs] going to get a job. 49:49 You'll probably start to see that become more prevalent too, but because of the transfer portal, not because of NIL. Mm-hmm. Okay, great. Last prediction before we move on to our upcoming ones for 2024. 49:59 This is one I had back in July. By the end of the year, Saudi Arabia's Public Investment Fund will be invested at least in a minority stake in an NBA team. 50:07 So this came off the back of some comments by, um, Adam Silver, who mentioned that they were open to foreign, uh, investment funds. 50:15 This was during that whole PGA-Liv Golf merger, and everybody kinda had to draw their own line in the sand as to whether or not they would accept oil money. Uh, Adam Silver said, "I would not be opposed." 50:26 And literally a week after this prediction, on June 23rd, the Qatar, uh, Public Wealth Fund, so not Saudi Arabia, but Qatar, announced a deal that landed them a 5% stake in Monu- Monumental Sports and Entertainment, which is the parent company of the Washington Wizards- Mm... 50:42 uh, Washington Mystics, and Washington Capitals ownership group. 50:45 And so pretty soon after those [laughs] comments were made by the commissioner, uh, pretty much a week after, uh, c- the Qatar Public Wealth Fund, uh, similar in kind to the Saudi Public Wealth Fund, um, had some stake in American sports. 50:58 I think I'll rate this as a triple. Um, it happened pretty quickly. It's obviously not the, the Saudi Public, uh, Investment Fund, we talked about this earlier, increasingly the only types of groups that can afford 51:08 professional sports teams are gonna be oil money and private equity firms. Yeah. And it seems like, uh, the NBA is not afraid to kinda cozy up to this, the, this kind of oil money. Yeah. I'll count it. We'll see. 51:22 Yeah, I mean, if the, uh, if the goal for a lot of these sports leagues is increasing valuation, you gotta go find where, where the money can, or the checks can be written, and the checks can be written with, uh, with [laughs] with sovereign public wealth funds out of, out of the Middle East. 51:34 All right, so 2024 predictions. Jake, let, let's rattle through these, uh, rather quickly. You can give a bit of explanation if you'd like. Um- Okay... let's alternate so that we can, we can- Sure... keep it fresh. 51:43 So my- We'll do it... first prediction, Netflix will buy the rights to the NBA in-season tournament for $100 million, and they're also going to create a content series around it. 51:56 So similar to how you saw them do, uh, the, the PGA or Drive to Survive, uh, very popularly, they want to get into live sports. They're gonna do that with the NBA in-season tournament. 52:05 The NBA obviously wants to be able to spin this in-season tournament into its own set of media rights to cash in. They get 100 million bucks. 52:13 Uh, Netflix gets to venture into live sports, and then they can also do what they do best, which is create really compelling unscripted content around one of the most drama-filled leagues in the world, the NBA. 52:25 Fair prediction. We'll see if it works out. Okay. Uh- Let's see. Go ahead... I'm gonna move mine around a little bit so we can go step for step in big streaming platform predictions. 52:33 I'm gonna say Amazon acquires Red Bull, the entire company. Wow, okay. Primarily as a way to get control of its sports content. I like that. I mean, I think for sim- Yeah, similar... 52:44 s- similar reasons to why Netflix would do it, right? I mean, they would- Right, but, but I just see- Different content... I also think that, like, 52:50 it actually makes a lot of sense for Amazon to do it because then they can control, like, the distribution of the Red Bull product on- Mm... 52:57 Amazon, and, like, they have a very profitable business that they're acquiring, not a, uh, a company that is, uh, profitable or just, like, a fledgling, um, sports property that's trying to be a bigger thing, um, than it, than it currently is. 53:13 And so they're able to get the benefits of that, but then they also get all of the content that Red Bull has oversight over. 53:20 Um, I think that's a really interesting audience for, uh, for Amazon to pull into its ecosystem. I like that prediction, Jake. That's a good one. Yeah. Little out of left field. It would be, it would be so fun. 53:29 It would be- Yeah. [laughs] Little out of left field. 53:31 All right, uh, my number two here, college, uh, there is going to be a college team, um, I can try to get specific for you at the end or, or give you a couple guesses of which college team it would be, but they are going to get funding from a minority investor, and I'm gonna give myself preemptive bonus points if it is [laughs] from a sovereign oil wealth fund like we talked about, either in Qatar or Saudi Arabia or the United Arab Emirates or something like that. 53:54 Um, my, my reasoning here is I think they would likely use that as these coaches' salaries we just saw with Jimbo Fisher, um, gets higher and higher. They're gonna use it for a massive buyout. 54:03 Um, there's already been reports by Florida State University, I think they're one of my, uh, prime, [laughs] prime, uh, predicting or prime- Yeah... 54:10 teams here to do this, to pay for their buyout to leave the ACC so that they could go to another conference for higher media rights, and I just think that in this next year, as the Big Ten finally folds in all those Pac-12 teams, the SEC gets Texas and Oklahoma, you're going to see a fervor, uh, you know, fervored pitch for more, better teams in more consolidated conferences because the media rights revenue is just going to be so, so, so, so, so high. 54:39 And, uh, I, I just think that Florida State and the ACC is gonna feel the pressure of this and say, "You know what? We need to get out. We need to get out now. 54:46 We're at risk of falling behind."We might, they might also do it for the reason of like, "Hey, we are stuck in this conference. We need more money to build new stadiums and better facilities to attract better talent. 54:56 We're gonna take outside investment to build a new stadium," or something like that. 55:00 Florida is one of the few states where they're allowed to do that, so if I were to add to my prediction, I think Florida State would be a team to, uh, to take private investment. Hmm. Interesting. Um, okay. 55:13 I mean, I, I'm wondering, I'm just trying to think what other schools might be able to do it and pull it off well. You know, it'd be interesting, maybe a private school could do it. 55:19 I don't know, I don't know how that works- Yeah... from a legal perspective. Maybe there's like a Stan- like a Stanford slides in. I think Stanford's private. Yeah. 55:25 I think they slide in and they're like, "Hey, like, we're just gonna bring in some extra money here." Yeah. Uh, no problem. Or I think a Notre Dame, like an independent would be a private candidate. Yeah. 55:33 Yeah, Notre Dame. I know they just signed a big media rights deal and, and that's how they continue to fund being an independent program, so- Yeah... they might, they might realize, like, "Hey, we need to..." 55:41 I, I just feel like they're still a little too into their pomp and circumstance, uh, Stanford included. 55:46 They're, like, a little too precious for that sort of thing, but I think, like, a Texas A&M, a Florida State, one of these schools that's like, has a really- Going all in, maybe... a really high self-esteem. But- Yeah... 55:57 maybe that self-esteem doesn't match their recent performance on the field. They're like, "You know what? Anything goes. Oil money in Texas spends just as good as oil money from Saudi Arabia. 56:06 Let's, let's go do this thing." Sure. Yeah, could work. [laughs] Um, my next one is an extension of what I already said about BeReal. Um, I think it, I think this is the year it comes crumbling down and- Wow... 56:20 uh- Vendetta against BeReal. No vendetta, it's just the reality. Like, you look at, look at the trend. You see, you see, like, this rapid spike up, and then- Mm-hmm... 56:28 you see this rapid spike down, and, um, the- they're gonna have to go out and raise another round of capital, and I think they're going to realize that nobody wants to fund what they're building. Fair enough. 56:42 [laughs] And they're gonna run out of money. Yeah. Fair enough. Well- That's it. Well, they're gonna have to lay off a bunch of people, uh, and then, and then, and then they're gonna have to shut it down, so. 56:49 Well, we'll be here when you're, when you're dancing on BeReal's grave. I won't, I won't dance on their grave. Oh. I'll light a candle maybe. Yeah, okay. 56:56 Uh, my final prediction for 2024, ESPN is not going to be sold by Disney. They're going to retain the brand, and ESPN Bet is going to become number two in the market. 57:07 I'll make a specific prediction that it'll dethrone DraftKings, which is currently number two in the market behind FanDuel in sports betting. I think there's a couple reasons for this. 57:16 Number one, Disney's in-person capabilities are better than any other, any other company. You, you see, like, in-person sports books making, uh, making a, a surgence, a surge across the country. 57:28 Really you have, you have sports venues putting in DraftKings and FanDuel sports books. Who does in-person theme park style or, you know, entertainment style venues better than anybody? 57:38 Disney and, and their big park structure. So I think there's a natural sportsbook fit, uh, with ESPN. We talked about it earlier, ESPN dominates sports media. 57:47 All these other sportsbook companies are trying to reverse engineer their way into media. ESPN just owns it outright and is the most trusted brand, so they have the distribution. 57:55 Uh, people are already familiar with the brand, and I think there increasingly is a good creative alignment, uh, with their talent. 58:02 You know, you see guys like Pat McAfee who talk a lot about betting, um, and now they have a place to send people. I, I just think everything's working. 58:09 There's going to be a total cash cow for Disney, probably paced over a lot of the decline they've seen in their linear business. 58:15 Uh, and I, and I still think that owning distribution for live sports is the best model to be in if you're gonna exist in linear television. 58:21 I think it's probably, you know, increasingly a, a bad proposition, a losing proposition to be in linear TV, but if there's any business you wanna be in, it's distributing live sports, and I think Disney is not gonna wanna get rid of that. 58:34 Yeah. 58:35 I, I, I, I appreciate that on a sports betting prediction, you parlayed your bet, or you parlayed your prediction, not only with the, the first part of ESPN staying with Disney, but secondarily with the betting app becoming number two in the market. 58:49 So if both of those things don't happen, it's a flop, but if they both do happen, you're gonna hit big. I hope so. 58:55 I, I think my odds are probably, like, plus a couple thousand, but, uh, I'll put a buck down and the payout will be big. Um, the next two things are a little scary for you on my end. 59:04 I added a late one about WhatsApp during this call, just 'cause I think it actually might happen. Um- Yeah... first one, the creator fund, so, like, 59:12 the subsidy programs that are happening on, like, TikTok and Snapchat and, and YouTube, I think they start to pull out the subsidy in those, and creator revenue starts to, to drop a little bit. 59:25 Not to, not to be scary or [laughs] anything- Yeah... but at some point, the, the subsidy will end, and, and right now it's just coming from the bottom line of the, the companies, and eventually- Sure... 59:36 they'll say, "Hey, now this gets passed down to, down to the creators." So it's a little bit scary, but I think that, that, that is a reality. Yeah. I, I'll, I'll push back on that. I obviously hope that's not true. 59:47 Yeah. Not that I'm hoping that it is true, but- No... um, I think you saw... So you used the word subsidy, which I think is interesting. I think you saw the traditional subsidy on TikTok even recently go away. 59:57 They just recently phased out their pro- their, um, [smacks lips] I forget what it was called. 1:00:02 It was just called their, the Creativity Fund or whatever it was, and that was a set pool of money, definitely a subsidy, where the company just said, "We're gonna put up a billion dollars to pay creators out of this set pool of money," and that went away. 1:00:13 But what remains is their, something called their Creativity Beta program, where it seems like, and I don't know how true this is, and you're right, the numbers might be inflated a little bit, um, but they're, they're pulling from ad revenue and paying creators a share of the ad revenue. 1:00:26 That's essentially what they're doing. Yeah, I just think, I think, I think it's more so, like, a percentage subsidy than at that point. Okay. 1:00:32 So, like, maybe they're, maybe they're paying out 10% of the revenue as opposed to- Yeah... the 5% that makes sense for their bottom line. Yeah, fair. I, I, I think I'm probably most concerned about it on Snapchat. 1:00:42 You brought that one up. Yeah. That seems totally unsustainable. Yeah. I think to rank them, I'm least concerned about YouTube. That's their- Me too... business model. Yeah, me too. 1:00:49 UmAnd TikTok, I think, will find itself increasingly competing with YouTube. Yeah. And I think that will keep the, the, the percentages high. I also think, Jake, like, 1:00:59 I think there's probably, maybe this comes from a, a place of hubris, there's probably gonna be more competition over the next year for short-form creators- Mm-hmm... to be on the platform. 1:01:07 That would indicate to me these percentages remain the same, maybe go up. But I respect your prediction, and we'll see where we end out next year. 1:01:14 There's gonna be no way for us to know if that actually happens, by the way. Well, we have better insight than most people. Like, I'll be able to look at my- Sure... you know. Sure. Yeah. 1:01:20 I'll be able to look and see, like, oh, shit, I, I [laughs]... share lots of money. Yeah. That, that could be it. The next thing, I was gonna say Tyler gets married. That's up to you. You could... It, uh- Yeah... 1:01:30 maybe it's a 2025 problem, but- It's, it's looking increasingly like a 2025 thing. 1:01:34 So for those of you who, who don't know, I got engaged recently, um, as of this episode coming out, the week of- If you're not following Tyler on his BeReal [laughs]... If you're following my BeReal, um, I got engaged. 1:01:45 Great day. Uh, it looks like 2024 might be a, a, a quick turnaround for a wedding, so we'll see. I, you put it into the, you put it in the record, and we'll see where we're at next year. Yep. It's in the universe. 1:01:57 It's in the universe. So there's only one, there's only two people that can prevent that from happening. [laughs] And I'm not one of them. You're not one of them. 1:02:05 And then the last thing, I think WhatsApp could definitely become a super app. Sure. I don't know. I think it's so under- That's something... Under le- It's so under-leveraged here in America, I feel like... 1:02:12 intentionally. Yeah. Very much so intentionally. Like, I think, so, uh, Facebook acquired it for, like, billions of dollars. It was Facebook at the time, now it's Meta. 1:02:22 Uh, and, uh, everyone's like, "Why would you do that?" Oh, WhatsApp has, like, billions of users. [laughs] Mm-hmm. That, that makes sense. 1:02:30 And now they're like, they're like very quietly and slowly turning on different tools and features and monetization, uh, uh, features that people [laughs] are able to take advantage of. 1:02:45 And, um, they're starting to get a little bit of advertising inside of the ecosystem, and you can advertise, uh, through, uh, Facebook Ad- Ads Manager, um, on, on the Meta side of things, into WhatsApp a little bit now too, which is, which is pretty interesting. 1:03:01 Um, and so they're starting to crank that in a little bit, and I think there's certainly a, a pathway that, that, that does happen. 1:03:11 Well, I think their biggest competitor would want something to say with that, being Apple. Yeah. 1:03:15 I think the, the reason WhatsApp is, is not fully integrated here is because we have, in America, pretty ubiquitously, like, the most, 1:03:23 the, the messaging service with the most walled garden, or just the ecosystem, the operating system with the, the thickest and the tallest walled garden, which is Apple. 1:03:30 And that, that whole blue bubble, green bubble dynamic is real. Um, Apple's recently been opening it up where now on Android it seems like, um, messages will... 1:03:41 You, you'll be able to see, like, read receipts, and you might be able to, like, double tap and see the, you know, likes and the exclamations on, on messages between Android and Apple. 1:03:49 But I think, uh, I think they'll want something to say about that whole super app, um, dynamic. And, and really- They already have one. Yeah. Ex- And that's what I was gonna say. 1:03:58 I think really when you consider a super app here in America, it is the Apple ecosystem. Yeah. Um, and I just think it's probably a, a tall task to ask a, an, an app like WhatsApp to, to overtake that. 1:04:09 Well, you just, you, you just have all of Meta, right? So you have to, like, big Zuck has to figure out how to integrate all the different pieces that they have. Yeah. We'll see. Which- We'll see if Zuck-... 1:04:21 tends to apply but in operating systems of other companies, so they don't really have their own operating system. They just have it in a different way. Yeah. They have a platform system. They have a platform system. 1:04:29 Well, in 2024, we'll see if it could be the year of the Zuck. All right, well- It's going to be. [laughs] Every, every year over the last, like, 25 years has been. Yeah, they keep printing money over there, man. 1:04:38 It's crazy. Yeah. All right. Well, this will be our last episode of the calendar year. Yeah. We consider with the holidays coming up, um, it's a busy time for everybody. 1:04:47 We will be back in 2024, so enjoy this, uh, this, this extra long episode, uh, regarding the predictions. 1:04:54 And a special thank you to Aaron and Ryan McFarlane for their help all throughout this year, uh, for producing this show, the clips that you see on social. 1:05:03 Uh, they've been integral in the helping this be a sustainable project for Jake and I, and we are, we're very appreciative to the both of them. We'll be back with more in sports and business next year. See you guys then. 1:05:14 [upbeat music]