Happy Wednesday,

This week I talked with one of the last of a dying breed of content creators.

Isaiah Lapp is a baseball YouTuber behind the Lapp Bros channel; however, that’s maybe the least interesting thing about him. That’s because he was actually born Amish, but after his parents left the church when he was 4, he became obsessed with becoming a YouTuber.

And early on, things looked promising:

  • One of his videos hit 5.1 million views when he was an early teenager

  • He made $30,000 from YouTube in a single year of high school

Even so, he spent years convinced it couldn’t be a real career, working a restaurant job and building a wedding film business on the side. But this year, he finally went all in, and today we'll cover how he grew up, why he resisted the creator label for so long, and how he’s rethinking his strategy now that YouTube is his full-time job.

âťť

My growth has never been a very steep spike. It’s only been over time.

— Isaiah Lapp

How Isaiah Got Here

  • Early years: Isaiah was born into an Amish family in a small Indiana town. When he was about four, his parents left the Amish church and the family was shunned, so they moved to Lancaster, Pennsylvania. The first thing his mom did after leaving was buy a camera.

  • Growing up: There was no TV and just one computer, which they used to watch the previous day’s baseball highlights and, once in a while, YouTube. His parents wouldn’t let the boys play football for fear of injuries, so they signed them up for Little League, and he and his two brothers fell in love with baseball.

  • 2015: As a teenager, he decided he wanted to be a YouTuber. He was the middle brother and the one who filmed, directed, and edited. His younger brother followed along, and his older brother was the line if things went too far.

  • The early videos: Isaiah’s parents were hesitant at first, and he had to convince them. They wanted everything wholesome and clean, with guidelines that expanded as he got older. Dude Perfect was his biggest influence, which is why his baseball content is still family-friendly.

  • The first hit: “Baseball Stereotypes (Inspired by Dude Perfect),” posted about nine years ago, now has 5.1 million views. It came after about two years of posting, and it made him think that if one video could reach that many people, another could too.

  • The overconfident follow-up: His next video was a two-minute short film called “The Unlucky Fisherman.” He thought he had made it and that anything he posted would be watched. It took about a year to post another baseball video, and two or three more years before he posted consistently.

  • High school: In his second year of being monetized, he made $30,000. He still worked at a restaurant for minimum wage, earning roughly $3,000 a year, and he paid his younger brother and anyone who helped. His dad had helped him set up AdSense and a bank account. He doesn’t know why he kept the other job.

  • After graduation: He never wanted to go to college, except to play baseball. He took a gap year in an experiential program with a Bible school component, then started a wedding film business from scratch in 2021.

  • The burnout: Weddings felt cookie-cutter after a while, but he was booked out two years in advance. He stopped taking bookings, and it took two years for the last ones to trickle out.

  • 2026: This is the first year he’s done YouTube full time. He has one wedding left, in the Virgin Islands.

The Big Idea: An 11-Year, Overnight Success

Isaiah’s channel never had a steep growth spike. He’s grown over ten years, which he says is what separates him from the many baseball channels exploding in popularity right now. His secret wasn’t a “hack”; it was that he kept posting. Videos from a dozen years ago are still on his channel, a record of everything he figured out in public.

The odd part is how hard he resisted. He had a 5.1 million-view video, a $30,000 year, and consistent hundreds of thousands of views, but he didn’t believe it was a real career. He thinks he may have been secretly embarrassed, since putting yourself out there wasn’t as common back then. What finally changed his mind was realizing the storytelling he loved in wedding films could live in his YouTube videos, with more freedom. After that, the pieces fit.

5 Tactical Takeaways

  1. Keep posting through the quiet years. Isaiah’s biggest video came early, and his output was inconsistent for years afterward. But he kept posting, and ten years of compounding is the advantage he has over newer channels.

  2. Borrow a proven format, then add originality. His early strategy was to take a title or format that worked for creators like Mr. Beast and make a baseball version. He says it worked because those formats have broad appeal. Now he’s adding originality so he isn’t just following trends.

  3. Learn packaging. If someone doesn’t click on a video, they won’t watch it. After making a great video, don’t slap on a thumbnail you spent 30 minutes on. Study click-through rate and average view duration, and plan hooks throughout the video, not just at the start.

  4. Collaborate earlier. Isaiah wishes he had realized sooner that other creators were on the same page and willing to share what they knew.

  5. Figure out the creative itch you’re not scratching. He kept going back to filmmaking because he missed emotional storytelling, which he found in wedding films. Once he realized he could do it on YouTube, he stopped splitting his attention. If you’re drawn to something outside your channel, ask whether you can bring it in.

Why It Matters

Isaiah’s story is becoming increasingly rare in a world of short-form content and recommendation-based algorithms. Today, it’s not uncommon to see someone “blow up” overnight, quit their job a month later, and launch a career as an influencer.

Isaiah, while just 24 years old, is from a different generation.

His growth was slow, accidental, and sometimes flat-out resisted. But it’s also a reflection of how he sees content. Not as some “get rich quick” scheme, but as a creative outlet as necessary to his existence as the air he breathes.

📩 And don’t forget: Bottom of the Ninth is back this Friday with the top three stories in sports and business from the week.

See you then,
Tyler & Jake